Religious freedom at stake in Egypt

By Osama Diab

If you don't during in , lie about it; hide it. Otherwise, you might land in jail.

26 August 2010

Tarek Elshabini, a 21-year-old engineering student, is , but only according to his personal ID card. Every year when Ramadan comes, he faces a dilemma: he doesn't fast because he's an atheist, but everyone, including officers, expects him to fast because he was born to a Muslim family.

In order to avoid any possible clashes between Elshabini and his family due to his non-religious credos, he decided to move away for a while until they are able to live with this new reality. Most families, in what was called the most religious country in the world by Gallup, would find it bitter to swallow the fact that their son does not believe God exists.

Elshabini managed to find a job in Hurghada as a bar tender in a night club to make his getaway, and on his second day in the Red Sea tourist city, he had to go to the police station to acquire the certificate of good conduct required by his new employer. After a few hours of struggling with governmental bureaucracy, Elshabini got his clean criminal record and was out of the police station at noon.

To kill his thirst, Elshabini stopped at the kiosk across from the police station for a soda. He stood there, bought a can of soda and lit a cigarette. Elshabini had no idea that last Ramadan at least 150 people were arrested in Aswan and Hurghada, where he just arrived, for eating, drinking or/and smoking in broad daylight during Ramadan. This was new and it was the first time it had occurred in Egypt.

It wasn't the last time though. This year, two micro-bus drivers were also arrested in Cairo for the same reason. A Ramadan crackdown was also carried out by police officers in Hurghada to arrest those who eat, smoke or drink publicly before sunset.

While Elshabini was smoking his cigarette and drinking his soda, a plain-clothed officer came up to him and asked what his name was before he invited him into the police station. “At this point, I thought that I might have forgotten something inside while getting my papers, and this very nice man was going to help me get it,” explains Elshabini.

The officer knew from his middle name, Ahmed, that he was a “Muslim”.

In Egypt, personal ID cards state the 's religions. The government of Egypt only recognises the three Abrahamic faiths: , Christianity and Judaism. Therefore, atheists like Tarek, have to state one of these religions in their ID cards.

The officer then told Elshabini he was arrested on the charge of “public breaking of the fast” and locked him up in detention. For three hours, no one would talk to him or tell him what was happening until the officer who arrested him came back. “I kept telling him I was sorry, and that I forgot that it was Ramadan and that I was fasting; anything just to get myself out of this,” says Elshabini.

Heba Morayef, a Human Right Watch researcher, explains that there is no such crime as “public breaking of the fast”. “The arrest of people for smoking in public during Ramadan is illegal under both Egyptian and international law. These arrests are arbitrary in the absence of any legal provisions under Egyptian law,” says Morayef.

After three hours of begging, Elshabini was finally released. “I'll believe you this time, and I'll let you off with no police report. How's that for a favor?” Elshabini says the officer told him.

Morayef also believes that these arrests seem to be occurring as a result of initiatives of individual police stations rather than a top-down policy by the ministry of interior. She believes, though, that this does not absolve the government of the responsibility for these illegal arrests. “The government must clearly issues instructions that its security officers do not have the right to arrest people who appear not to be fasting,” she adds.

“Ramadan is the time of year that I would very much like to disappear from the face of the earth. Everybody is badly infected with this mass religious hysteria, and people start to interfere in other people's business,” says Elshabini.

The story of Elshabini shows how Egypt's relatively secular police is becoming increasingly intolerant when it comes to freedom of . It also demonstrates the government's failure to acknowledge that there are people who might not believe in Islam, Christianity or Judaism. Egyptian law still does not address this issue either. Until last year, members of the Baha'i faiths had to write Muslim on their ID cards because the law does not recognise the Baha'ism as a religion. Last year, the court allowed Baha'is to choose to leave the religion field blank.

These arrests also show that freedom of religion and is in danger in Egypt which has always been known for its relative religious tolerance, especially in contrast with more theocratic regimes in the region, such as and most of the Gulf countries, Sudan and Iran, but for a second year in a row, this seems to be changing, at least on an unofficial level.

“After three of the most humiliating hours in my life, I couldn't believe what was happening. At some point, I thought that this was a TV show or something; that this was a trick, but unfortunately, every part of what happened was real,” says Elshabini.

However, many Egyptians are against these arrests. A facebook group called ‘Egyptians from all beliefs are against the arresting of non-fasters in Ramadan' attracted some 800 members in just a few days. “Respect expected by people who fast should be based on personal choice,” says Hany Freedom, the creator of the online group who chose to go by his Facebook name. “Otherwise, how would the faster know if others are considerate out of conviction or only because they are forced to.”

This article first appeared in The Staggers blog of The New Statesman on 23 August 2010. Republished here with the author's permission. Read comments on this article here. ©Osama Diab. All rights reserved.

Author

For more insights

Sign up to receive the latest from The Chronikler

We don't spam!

For more insights

Sign up to receive the latest from The Chronikler

We don't spam!

13 thoughts on “Religious freedom at stake in Egypt

  • Rasha Adil Hilal

    Mona, yes it would be great to have him join the discussion, again my point is either it is fabricated or it is a one-time experience after all Osama is one person not 80 million. 5 years ago I’ve been illegally detained for 2-3 hours by co…rrupt police men for taking photos of people buying bread outside an old bakery, I was questioned if i were a CNN reported, and they were obviously very rude people who tried to confiscate my mobile phone so I dont call for help, I had to shout back as i phoned my dad who came in to pick me up. this incident was not based on any law neither did it happen every day back then, the informant lady probably wanted money that i refused to give and i might have looked like a rich stranger in her eyes. Yes the Wahabbi influence is increasing in Egypt in a sickening way, although it’s no where near the police force. We should not confuse the normal with the abnormal.

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Osama Diab

    Mohamed, if you read the article til the end, I make it clear that Egypt is not like Saudi or Sudan and is much more tolerant than some of the theocratic regimes of the region. I am just afraid that this might be changing.

    When the case of M…arwa Elsherbini was reported no one accused the reporter of enforcing stereotypes, but in Egypt we tend to live in denial and accuse everything on reporting, especially when it appears in a foreign publication, rather than trying to actually solve the problems being reported, or at least bother to see if they are true.

    The fact that you drank in public without being arrested is a poor argument. I know someone who double-parked before without getting a ticket.

    Shoshanna, it’s Gallup who said this. I personally don’t think it’s necessarily true.

    Rasha, I seriously don’t know what to say to that. But as a journalist, you think I will write something that sensitive without having my back covered? You can search the topic a bit, or even go find Tarek on facebook and ask him yourself. He’s on my list of friends. One of the commenters actually said that she knows Tarek herself. I did not invent Tarek.

    Mona, thanks for inviting me to enage in the debate. It is interesting to see what people say about your articles when you’re not watching 🙂

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Sahar Omar

    I believe every word in this article. Egypt is heavily influenced by the Wahhabies today, that is a fact, any one cannot see that is in denial. Its a diffrerent country from the one I knew 🙁

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Mona Eltahawy

    Rasha – accusing Osama of making this story up is a serious charge. I understand if your experience has shown you otherwise but it’s unfair to accuse Osama of making it all up. He’s a journalist whose work I have followed for a while and I’m sure he would not fabricate anything. I will ask him if he wants to join the discussion.

    Via Facebook

    Reply
    • Mona, were you charged for the offenses you committed in the USA? just asking 🙂

      Reply
  • Rasha Adil Hilal

    no it’s not true and I believe that this article has been fabricated, it is no way close to what happens in Egypt, despite the fact that worst things happen in Egypt and that the police are corrupt, if this incident has happened then it is just a one time occurence most probably for other reasons not related to breaking the fast

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Shoshanna Negron

    Well the article did say ‘might’ get arrested. And the dude stood in front of a police station drinking and smoking…and we all no the police in Egypt are an arrogant bunch of assholes and those are the good ones…so I guess it depends on the mood of the cop at the time. Still I wouldn’t take any chances as I know my ass would be in a jail cell! I was a little alarmed by the writers comment that ‘Egypt is one of the most religious countries in the world’ really?? Is that true?

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Mohamed Abdelfattah

    That article helps enforce a stereotype that rarely exists. Yes arrests were unusually made last year. But this year I deliberately drank and eaten in public and in the countryside and no one even looked at me. When someone asked me ( including my relative ) why? I told him i’m on travel and so tired. He then offered me lunch and more drinks. I hate those writers who seek to sell out a story because it will ring in some people’s ears and satisfy their stereotypes.

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Al-Hussainy Mohamed

    that doesn’t apply all the time .. I’m not fasting today and spent about half of the day in streets and no one arrested me.

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Ahmed Atef

    good article Osama, even if I don’t agree it is our priority now 😉

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Hany Freedom

    Thanks Osama …… i appreciate it.

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Tarek Elshabini

    Thanks man, this needed to get out

    Via Facebook

    Reply
  • Excellent article! It says it all…

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

error

Enjoyed your visit? Please spread the word