Half a day with the “last Arab Jew”

By Khaled Diab

, critic and friend of the late Egyptian Nobel laureate Naguib Mahfouz, believes transcends and can bridge cultures.

Wednesday 1 August 2012

النسخة العربية

These are troubling times for -Israeli relations. Arabs watch on with rising alarm as continues to cement its hold on the occupied Palestinian territories and toys with the idea of denying that there even is an occupation. Meanwhile, Israelis look on with mounting apprehension as Egypt elects the unknown quantity of its first Islamist president and Syria slips further into civil war.

Amid all this uncertainty and distrust, one man insists on keeping his feet firmly planted on both sides of this chasm. Sasson Somekh describes himself as both a Jew and an Arab, as both Iraqi and Israeli.

This poet, academic, writer and translator of literature into Hebrew invited me to spend “half a day” with him, in a witty allusion to a little-known short story by Egyptian Nobel laureate Naguib Mahfouz. Penned in the latter years of Mahfouz's prolific career, this allegorical tale relates the events of just half a day in which the narrator enters the school gate for the first time as a young boy in the morning and emerges as an old man in the afternoon.

“How could all this have happened in half a day, between early morning and sunset?” the elderly narrator asked, perplexed.

I wondered the same, as this sharp-witted tortoise of a man, slow of body but swift of mind, snailed through time and space to take me on a riveting journey from the contemporary Israel of his silver years, back to the disappeared world of his youth, Jewish Baghdad (which he eloquently evokes in the first part of his memoirs, Baghdad, Yesterday), via the literary salons of his middle age in Egypt.

Born in Baghdad in 1933 into a well-to-do, middle-class Jewish family, Somekh remembers summers spent swimming in and loungingby the majestic Tigris, the river along whose banks some of the first human civilisations were born. When temperatures soared and water levels dipped, a patchwork of small islets would emerge, providing ideal seclusion for family picnics, consisting primarily of fish grilled on a special covered Iraqi barbecue. “Those were the most enjoyable days of my life,” he recalled wistfully.

At the time, Baghdad was a very Jewish city, with Jews – who were active in all walks of life, including commerce, the professions, politics and the arts – comprising as much as a third of the Iraqi capital's population. “When you walked down Baghdad's main street, al-Rashid, half the names on the shops and offices were Jewish,” he noted.

Iraqi Jews were so enmeshed in their country's social fabric that they described themselves, and were regarded, as “Arabs”, and viewed Judaism as a religion and not an ethnicity. As Somekh put it, he grew up with Arabic as his mother tongue and Arab as his reference point.

The ancient Jewish presence in Iraq led to some interesting cultural symbioses: Iraqi Jews traditionally wrote Arabic in Hebrew script and Baghdadi Jews spoke a vernacular that had died out among Muslims and Christians. Jews also affected Iraq's daily life. For example, Somekh recalls, some Shi'ites, who worked for Jewish businesses switching their own day of worship to Saturday, the Jewish Sabbath, during which Muslim neighbours often helped perform tasks Jews were ritually forbidden to carry out, such as lighting stoves.

Despite the image in Israel of Middle Eastern Jews being very traditional and religious, the educated or wealthy Jewish elites did not keep Sabbath and were very secular. Somekh, whose father was a senior clerk at a British bank, grew up knowing very little about his religious heritage, which was not even taught at the Jewish schools he attended.

During his teenage years, Somekh was a promising young poet who hung out in Baghdad's vibrant literary salons and managed to get some of his published. But his youthful dreams of a glittering literary career in his homeland were rudely interrupted by history and the shifting tectonic plates of geopolitics.

Though the vast majority of Iraqi Jews played no part in what befell the , they were nonetheless blamed for it. And by 1951 the situation had become untenable.

Iraqi Jewish refugees in Israel were, like the Palestinians, settled in makeshift camps, a huge step down for the Somekhs from the comfort and prestige they had enjoyed in Baghdad. But eventually the family got back on its feet, and the young Sasson Somekh refused to give up on his literary dreams. “Literature is literature. Politics does not enter into it,” he told me with disarming simplicity.

Somekh not only became involved with the only Israeli literary magazine in Arabic at the time, one run by the Israeli communist movement, he also redoubled his efforts to learn Hebrew so that he could translate Arabic poetry into this new-old .

Somekh's crowning achievement was to become one of the foremost authorities on Naguib Mahfouz. When Somekh first took an interest in the Egyptian novelist, Mahfouz was almost unknown outside the Arab world. As there was so little information available on Mahfouz's literature in English, the Nobel committee, according to Somekh, relied heavily on his PhD thesis to assess the Egyptian novelist's work.

Intellectual interest soon blossomed into an improbable and controversial (given the Arab boycott of Israel) friendship between the Egyptian writer and his Israeli critic. The two men kept up a correspondence for years, and the pen pals were finally able to further their friendship when Somekh moved to Cairo in the mid-1990s, to head the Israeli Academic Centre.

“Our two peoples knew extraordinary partnership,” Mahfouz once confided in Somekh. “I dream of the day when, thanks to the co-operation between us, this region will become a home overflowing with the light of science, blessed by the highest principles of heaven.”

And it is this vision of eventual Arab-Israeli conciliation that Somekh – who describes himself as the “last Arab Jew” because his is the last generation of Jews that clearly remembers living in peace among Arabs – seems to have dedicated his life to through his attempts to build bridges of cultural understanding.

Though he admits that his efforts have not yielded any significant results, he labours on regardless. And perhaps one day, in a more peaceful future, we will look back on Somekh and Mahfouz and others like them not as misguided eccentrics, but as bold visionaries.


This is the extended version of an article which was first published by The Common Ground News Service on Tuesday 31 July 2012.


For more insights

Sign up to receive the latest from The Chronikler

We don't spam!

For more insights

Sign up to receive the latest from The Chronikler

We don't spam!

15 thoughts on “Half a day with the “last Arab Jew”

  • Pingback: Half a day with the “last Arab Jew” | The Chronikler « What do you REALLY think?

  • Pingback: mars (Rebecca) | thecommonillsbackup

  • Pingback: Iraq snapshot (C.I.) | thecommonillsbackup

  • Joe Samuels

     Somech’s story brings a vivid memory of my life in Baghdad. I am three years older than he is and lived in my ancestors land for 19 years.

    My life and many of the Iraqi Jews were mixed bags. There was the deep sense of true Arabic friendship with Muslims, and the sense of fear of others.

    The joy of swimming in the Tigress, the smell  of the Mazgouf, BBQ Shaboot fish in Al Jazra, the island that appears in the summer when the water level is engraved, alive and well  in my memory. The Farhud of June1 & 2 1941, when Muslim mobs killed many Jews and looted and burnt hundred of Jewish homes and businesses is the ugly part in mixed bag. I was 11 years old. And finally how we were treated in 1948, after the Iraq’s failed war against Israel, with contempt, arrest, torture and execution left another scars of being no more wanted. I was smuggled out in Dec. 1949. I was lucky.

    Thanks Sasson for your well written article and your attempt to bridge the gap to bring peace with our Arab brethren  and neighbors.
    Joseph Samuels

    • KhaledDiab

       Thank you, Joe, for sharing your own recollections.

      • Have a look at the comments this guy posts about Palestinians on his Facebook page. Whilst he weeps his petty “tragedy”, he is very much in favour of permanent occupation of Palestine. And he lies when he says that 130,000 Iraqi Jews were made to leave their ancestral homes.

        Historian Avi Shlaim, also an Iraqi-born Israeli Jew, said of the Jewish exodus from Iraq (source: Haaretz):

        “[T]he [Iraqi] government issued a law that any Iraqi – they wrote `Iraqi’ rather than `Jew’ specifically – who wanted to leave the country, could leave if he registered by a certain date, but would have to surrender his citizenship. [snip] Out of the 130,000 Jews in Iraq, 100,000 registered, including my father. (…) We are not refugees, nobody expelled us from Iraq, nobody told us that we were unwanted.”

  • Interesting stuff Khaled. Half a day, a lifetime spent, in time’s worn passage we still lament!

    • KhaledDiab

       Very poetic, Christian. Are you paraphrasing someone or is that verse your creation?

  • “Though the vast majority of Iraqi Jews played no part in what befell the Palestinians, they were nonetheless blamed for it.” – So Jews were driven out of Arab countries and Arab were driven out of Israel. The only difference is that the Balestinians have been kept as refugees and were never allowed to settle in the Arab countries they went to who ‘care’ about them so much.. 

    • Does that make you feel less guilty about driving them out?

      It is strange that you’ll find more Israelis complaining about the Palestenian conditions in the recipient Arab countries than the Palestinians themselves.

      That’s from personal experience !

      • The Jews of Israel-Palestine drove the Arabs out in wartime, to save their own lives.  Arab nationalists drove the Jews out of Baghdad (Cairo and etc) to loot their properties. 

        • The largest migration wave of Palestinians out of their lands preceded the 1948 war (cf. Israeli historian Avi Shlaim).

          And after the expulsion of Palestinians, their properties, lands and bank accounts were seized by Israel and given away to European Jewish immigrants. This is how Israel managed to become a Jewish majority land. Before 1948, Jews owned less than 7% of historic Palestine. They managed to increase their share of the territory by expelling Palestinians and confiscating their goods. Needless to say, Palestinians have been unable to return to their lands to reclaim their properties and have received no compensation from the wealthy state of Israel — and this, at the same times that Israel demands that compensation be given by European states to the descendants of Jewish victims of WW2.

          Supposing Arab states have indeed driven out their Jews, and so they could loot their properties, then the same can be said of Israel’s intentions by expelling Palestinians.

          Have in mind that it was never Israel’s intention to have a Palestinian neighbor. Zionists have always wanted to expand to the whole of Palestine by means of military conquest and ethnic cleansing.

          David Ben Gurion wrote as early as the 1930s:

          “”After the formation of a large army in the wake of the establishment of the state, we will abolish partition and expand to the whole of Palestine.”

    • newsjunkies

      Ziv, Israelis are always looking for any angle to exonerate themselves from their crimes against the human race and the 7.7 Million Palestinians whose lands and lives they stole. Every Israeli who is not against the occupation is a criminal and a murderer. And lastly don’t even try to make your case that Jews and Israelis are the same. Israelis are the criminals, and Jews who are not israelis are innocent human beings like the rest of the world.

    • You guys are crazy to have Palestinians absorbed by neighboring Arab states, so they will forget the lands, homes and money that Jews stole from them. You’ll probably do the same to West Bank Palestinians and then ask Jordan to deal with the mess that your ethnic cleansing enterprise will create.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Enjoyed your visit? Please spread the word